Author Jonah Lehrer is really very sorry about lying

Jonah-Lehrer_510x317.jpg

Image Credit: Thos Robinson/Getty Images

Jonah Lehrer — wunderkind science writer, former New Yorker contributor, and plagiarizer — would like to apologize.

Or, in Lehrer’s own words, “I am the author of a book on creativity that contained several fabricated Bob Dylan quotes. I committed plagiarism on my blog, taking, without credit or citation, an entire paragraph from the blog of Christian Jarrett. I also plagiarized from myself.”

This week, Lehrer was invited by the Knight Foundation to speak. And many wondered what, exactly, he would say — or rather, how, and how often, and to whom, would he apologize?

His 20-plus minute, 3,500 word speech (available here and here) is an apology.

“At the time my career fell apart, I was working on an article about the mental flaws that plague forensic researchers,” he says. “These are flaws that, if left unchecked, can lead to false matches and wrongful convictions.”

A majority of his remarks expand on this work; and, by-proxy, ignore some of the bloodier score-settling that his critics might have hoped for. It’s a nice piece of backdoor reporting, turning his own failures into the foundation for spotlighting other, larger ones. It is also, yes, contrite, with space to quote both Joan Didion and Bob Dylan (for real this time) and peppered with the perspective of easy omniscience that makes his work readable…and suspect.

Ultimately, these cautionary tales — footnoted all — will serve as a road map for his redemption. It was nice that he got to fail almost as bad as the FBI. “And that’s why I need my new standard procedures,” he says. “They are a forcing function, forcing me to deal with my own bad decisions.”

The speech begins with the hope, at some eventual point, for forgiveness. But Lehrer seems to have changed his mind by the end, looking instead toward “the possibility of improvement. Not redemption, not forgiveness.”

What do you think of the “I’m sorry”? And where does it rank in the pantheon of disgraced journalism apologies?

Read more:
Author Jonah Lehrer resigns from ‘The New Yorker’ after admitting to faking Bob Dylan quotes
Book review: ‘Proust Was a Neuroscientist’

Latest Videos in Books

Advertisement

From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP